Choosing the best AR15 magazine can make a noticeable difference in your firearm's performance, durability, and reliability. Each manufacturer has its own approach to materials, features, and design, all of which can impact how your AR15 performs. Today, we’re taking a close look at Colt magazines, Magpul PMAGs, Magpul Windowed PMAGs, Lancer magazines, SureFeed army-issued magazines, and Duramags to help you find the right fit for your shooting needs.
1. Old School Colt Magazines
Colt AR15 magazines have long been a staple in the AR15 community and are often considered the benchmark for metal magazines. Originally produced for the U.S. military, they have a straightforward design.
- Price: Colt magazines are reasonably priced, typically between $10 and $20, depending on whether you purchase new or surplus.
- Quality: Colt’s magazines are known for reliability. They use aluminum construction, which keeps them lightweight and durable.
- Reliability: As a military-issued mag, Colt magazines have seen action and field use for decades. They are reliable (depending on what generation follower you have) and favored by enthusiasts who want a classic or historically accurate magazine.
- Downside: The aluminum construction is sturdy but can dent or bend with rough handling. Also, while functional, Colt magazines lack modern features like anti-tilt followers or windows to indicate ammo count.
2. Magpul PMAGs
Magpul PMAGs are a popular choice among both civilian and military users, as they combine innovation with reliability. Made from reinforced polymer, PMAGs are known for their lightweight, durable design.
- Price: Magpul PMAGs are very affordable, ranging from $9 to $15. This makes them an attractive choice for shooters looking to stock up on high-quality AR15 magazines.
- Quality: Magpul has created a reputation for manufacturing durable and reliable polymer magazines that withstand rough conditions. The polymer resists impacts better than metal, avoiding dents or deformation.
- Reliability: PMAGs are built to be dependable in a variety of environments. They feature an anti-tilt follower and a self-lubricating design that contributes to consistent feeding.
- Downside: While highly durable, PMAGs are not favored by users who prefer traditional metal construction. Otherwise, I don't see any downsides to PMAGs.
3. Magpul Windowed PMAGs
The Windowed PMAGs by Magpul bring additional functionality by including transparent windows to show the approximate remaining rounds. They are often chosen by competition shooters and those who want real-time feedback on their ammo count.
- Price: Windowed PMAGs typically cost a few dollars more than standard PMAGs, coming in around $15 to $18.
- Quality: Built with the same reinforced polymer as standard PMAGs, these magazines are durable, lightweight, and feature Magpul’s well-regarded reliability.
- Reliability: In addition to anti-tilt followers, the windowed models provide a quick visual of ammunition count, allowing users to plan reloads better.
- Downside: These windowed versions can slightly increase the price point, which may be a minor drawback for budget-conscious buyers. However, the benefit of seeing your ammo count might outweigh this for serious users.
4. Lancer Magazines
Lancer magazines offer a unique blend of polymer and steel construction, combining the benefits of both materials. These magazines are lightweight yet incredibly strong.
- Price: Lancer magazines are on the higher end, typically priced between $15 and $25.
- Quality: Lancer uses polymer for the body with steel feed lips, making them among the most durable AR15 magazines available. They resist deformation and cracking even with heavy use.
- Reliability: The hybrid construction results in a magazine that is resistant to feed lip spread, a common issue with all-polymer magazines after prolonged use. This hybrid design enhances reliability, making Lancer a favorite among tactical and competition shooters.
- Downside: The higher price might deter some users. However, for those willing to invest in durable, long-lasting magazines, the added cost is generally considered worthwhile.
5. SureFeed Army-Issued Magazines
SureFeed magazines (formerly produced by Okay Industries) are U.S. Army-issued magazines that are built to meet military specifications, ensuring high standards of quality and reliability.
- Price: SureFeed magazines are reasonably priced, generally between $12 and $15.
- Quality: These magazines are made from aluminum with a Teflon-coated finish, which adds corrosion resistance and smoother operation.
- Reliability: SureFeed magazines are engineered to meet military standards, which makes them one of the most reliable AR15 magazines for tactical use. The anti-tilt follower and rigorous quality control enhance feeding consistency.
- Downside: As with Colt magazines, the aluminum construction can dent if handled roughly. However, their military-grade quality control often makes up for this drawback.
6. Duramags
Duramags offer a range of steel and aluminum magazines and are known for their durability and strong performance.
- Price: Duramags are fairly priced, ranging from $12 to $20 depending on the model and material.
- Quality: Duramags are available in both steel and aluminum, giving users the option to choose between lightweight or heavy-duty materials. They are designed for high performance and feature enhanced anti-tilt followers.
- Reliability: These magazines are reliable in high-stress situations, making them popular among law enforcement and civilian users alike. The anti-tilt follower and reliable spring system help ensure consistent feeding.
- Downside: Steel Duramags can be heavier than other magazines on this list. However, they make up for it in durability and long-lasting performance.
Final Comparison: Which AR15 Magazine is Right for You?
When choosing AR15 magazines, it ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and personal preferences. Here’s a quick summary to help you decide:
- Colt Magazines: Great for traditionalists and those who want authentic military-style magazines. Affordable but lacks modern features.
- Magpul PMAGs: Durable, lightweight, and a great all-around choice for most users. A good mix of price and reliability.
- Magpul Windowed PMAGs: Ideal for those who want the added benefit of a visual ammo count. Slightly higher price, but excellent for tactical and competitive use.
- Lancer Magazines: A hybrid design with high durability and feed lip strength. Best for users willing to invest in long-lasting quality.
- SureFeed Army-Issued Magazines: Reliable, military-grade quality at an affordable price. Great for those who want high performance on a budget.
- Duramags: Good value and available in both steel and aluminum for different weight and durability preferences. Ideal for users who prioritize performance over weight.
Each of these AR15 magazines has its pros and cons, but all are capable of delivering reliable performance under the right circumstances. Whether you prioritize cost, durability, or a specific feature, this guide should help you find the best magazine for your AR15 setup. Personally, I always go with Magpul PMAGs since they are cheap and easy to "stack deep". Buying a 10 pack of PMAGs is generally around $100 and a fantastic way to spend a little money, especially if your state has the potential to ban 30 round magazines.
By considering these factors, you’ll be equipped to choose the AR15 magazine that best aligns with your needs and preferences, making your shooting experience safer and more enjoyable.
